If you’re a Murderino, or just a die-hard fan of true crime, then you’re probably always on the hunt for your next chilling read from the best true crime book boxes available.
But what if the most gripping stories could show up at your door each month, complete with exclusive extras, author notes, and even murder mystery games? Welcome to the world of true crime book boxes.
With so many options out there, we’ve rounded up the most popular true crime-themed book subscription boxes and compared them on price, content, uniqueness, and overall Murderino appeal.
Whether you love investigative journalism, historical crime, or interactive experiences, there’s a box for you. Here are the top 10 true crime book boxes, especially curated for you.
📦 1. The Deadbolt Mystery Society
🕵️♀️ Best for: Interactive crime-solving fans
- Price: $25.99/month
- Includes: Standalone murder mystery game, often includes a true crime-style story, puzzles, and immersive details
- Delivery: Monthly
- Bonus: Digital hints and community forums for solving together
Why Murderinos Love It: It’s more than a book—it’s a game. If you love the thrill of connecting clues and playing detective, this box offers an experience you won’t forget.
📚 2. Once Upon a Book Club – True Crime Editions
🔎 Best for: Readers who love themed extras and immersive reading
- Price: ~$49.99 per box (quarterly or special release)
- Includes: 1 full-length true crime book, 3–5 wrapped gifts related to story content, quote cards, live discussion events
- Delivery: Special edition releases (not monthly)
Why Murderinos Love It: Gifts are opened as you reach certain pages in the book, making the reading experience immersive and engaging. Think bookmarks with blood splatter, evidence bags, or replica letters.
🧳 3. My Thrill Club – Mystery & Thriller Option
📘 Best for: Budget-conscious readers who still want a thrill
- Price: $18.99/month
- Includes: 2 new hardcover books in either Mystery, Thriller, or Horror genre
- Delivery: Monthly
- Bonus: Sometimes includes lesser-known true crime or crime-inspired fiction
Why Murderinos Love It: While not strictly a true crime box, it delivers the dark, suspenseful content Murderinos crave—often at a fraction of the price.
🧠 4. Criminal Content (by Hunt A Killer)
🔬 Best for: Fans of Hunt A Killer who want more narrative
- Price: ~$35/month
- Includes: Serialized fiction and true crime-inspired stories with documents, props, and puzzles
- Delivery: Monthly
- Bonus: Interactive elements like interviews, case files, and timelines
Why Murderinos Love It: Combines storytelling with the thrill of an investigation. It’s like living inside a true crime docuseries.
🔍 5. Finders Seekers: Mystery Subscription Box
🧩 Best for: Puzzle-lovers who enjoy real-world settings
- Price: $30/month
- Includes: A mystery rooted in culture and history with clues, codes, and ciphers
- Delivery: Monthly
- Bonus: Each box is set in a new city or country with historical crime influence
Why Murderinos Love It: Great for those who love puzzles, history, and international true crime. Some storylines are based on real crimes or folklore.
📖 6. Books That Matter: True Crime Edition (UK-Based)
🇬🇧 Best for: Socially conscious readers
- Price: Varies (limited edition releases)
- Includes: True crime book with feminist themes, author commentary, and exclusive extras
- Delivery: Special edition boxes, not monthly
- Bonus: Focuses on justice, women in crime, and critical analysis
Why Murderinos Love It: A thoughtful approach to true crime—perfect for fans who want depth and social context.
🔪 7. Murder Mystery in a Box
📦 Best for: Fully immersive monthly mysteries
- Price: $29.99/month
- Includes: Murder mystery case, evidence, photos, interviews, and puzzles
- Delivery: Monthly
- Bonus: Some boxes are based on real historical crimes
Why Murderinos Love It: A hands-on experience that mixes fiction with realism. Perfect for those who want more than just a book.
📚 8. The Book Drop – The “Books for Binge-Watchers” Option
🎥 Best for: Fans of true crime TV and Netflix docuseries
- Price: ~$17–$21/month
- Includes: 1 handpicked book monthly with a “binge-worthy” feel
- Delivery: Monthly
- Bonus: Curated by independent booksellers, often includes thrillers and true crime-style fiction
Why Murderinos Love It: A less “gimmicky,” more literary option for readers who love bingeable crime content.
🧠 9. The Mystery Book Box by My Coffee and Crime
☕ Best for: Cozy true crime and coffee lovers
- Price: ~$35/month
- Includes: 1 mystery or crime book, coffee/tea, bookmarks, themed gifts
- Delivery: Monthly
- Bonus: Small business with a cozy-crime twist—ideal for relaxing mystery fans
Why Murderinos Love It: Combines crime fiction with relaxing vibes. A fun gift for fans who want suspense without all the gore.
📦 10. Hunt A Killer – Murder Mystery Box
🧠 Best for: True crime fans who want to play detective over time
- Price: Starts at ~$30/month
- Includes: A multi-episode murder mystery delivered in monthly “episodes” with evidence, case files, autopsy reports, and realistic documents
- Delivery: Monthly (cases span 6 months)
- Bonus: Realistic storytelling and immersive plotlines based on fictional crimes—but inspired by real forensic techniques
Why Murderinos Love It: This is the gold standard of narrative crime experiences. It’s like starring in your own serial podcast—with clues to uncover and suspects to interrogate.
Related article:- Best Hunt A Killer games to test your detective skills
🧩 Final Thoughts
Whether you’re a seasoned sleuth or just starting your true crime obsession, these subscription boxes offer something for every type of Murderino. Each box brings the mystery right to your mailbox—and might just be your next favorite obsession.